•

Ep. 340 — Sell Trust, Not Tours: Winning B2B Contracts, Pricing for Profit and Building a DMC That Delivers

In student travel, the person you sell to is rarely the one who travels. Harry Alvarez of Offbeat Travel walks Mitch through how B2B buyers decide, how he prices for a partner versus a direct client, and why he walked away from one partnership over margin.

In student travel, the person you sell to is rarely the one who travels. It’s a teacher, a group leader or another travel company, and once they trust you, they can send you every group they have for your country. Earning that trust takes a long time, and keeping it depends on what happens on the ground. Harry Alvarez co-founded Offbeat Travel, which runs student programs in the Dominican Republic, Costa Rica and Puerto Rico for other travel companies, and now sells trips directly to travelers as well.

Harry’s conclusion is that you’re selling a relationship, and that bending on price to win or keep one has cost him money and left guests less happy. Listen to this one if you sell through partners, or if you’ve thought about going after school and group business. You’ll come away knowing how these buyers decide, how to price for a partner versus a direct client, and when a partnership has stopped making sense.

Resources:

Key Takeaways

  • If your ground team sits idle in the off season, hand ground operations to a local DMC. 03:18 to 03:59 Keeping your own staff on the ground all year isn’t always financially viable in a seasonal market like student travel, because you pay people for months with no programs. Rustic Pathways’ new owners reached that conclusion during a sale. They spun the ground teams out into an independent DMC, Offbeat Travel, which signed Rustic as its first client. For the people on the ground, the old employer works as an incubator: you start with a client and a team that already know each other.
  • Travel companies cut their own ground teams in the pandemic, and many now need an outside operations arm. 05:21 to 06:00 Coming out of COVID, companies had cut overhead by letting go of staff in their destinations. Many of those people took other jobs during a year and a half without travel. When trips came back, those companies needed ground teams and were more willing to talk to a DMC. That opened doors for Offbeat when it reopened in 2021.
  • Pay local staff every severance the law requires. 06:00 to 06:40 The Dominican Republic and Costa Rica have strict severance laws, and during the pandemic many foreign companies operating there didn’t follow them. Locals became dispensable. Offbeat paid out every severance when it shut down. Its mission grew out of that: local ownership, partnering with locals, and giving local operators an equal seat at the table.
  • Train local leaders to run most programs, and keep a few staff from your clients’ home country. 06:40 to 07:12 In 2008, three or four of the 50 summer staff hired for Costa Rica programs were Costa Rican, and the rest were flown in. Now most of Offbeat’s program leaders are locals it trained, which gives the programs a local flavor. It still hires some staff from the US and elsewhere because they understand the client.
  • When loyal guests want new destinations, weigh a DMC’s help against the margin and control you keep by booking direct. 07:12 to 08:07 An operator with a loyal following keeps getting asked for new and more exotic places, often ones it doesn’t know from the ground up. A DMC fills that gap. Booking things direct keeps far more of the margin, though, and a DMC isn’t always a great partner or as invested in your brand as you are.
  • Direct bookings tend to come out cheaper for the traveler, with higher satisfaction. 08:07 to 08:56 B2B is 60 to 70 percent of Offbeat’s business and still its bread and butter. The company started at 100 percent student travel. Adults, independent travelers and families now make up 15 to 30 percent depending on the year, mostly booked direct and sometimes through OTAs. Those trips are more affordable for the end user, and satisfaction tends to run higher.
  • Protect an exclusive wholesale partner, and control the whole trip when a guest books you direct. 08:56 to 09:35 One exclusive partner on the ground can bring hundreds of clients a year, and that’s a relationship to protect. When a traveler comes to you directly, you control the experience from beginning to end. Expectations are set better and less gets lost in translation.
  • End a partnership when the partner sells your trip as something more expensive than what you deliver. 09:35 to 10:02 Offbeat’s first client breakup came from that gap. Guests arrived expecting more, based on what they had paid the partner, while the trip matched what the partner had bought from Offbeat. Your team on the ground can do a lot, but a big gap between what guests feel they paid and what they get is very hard to get past.
  • Treat departing staff well, because they’re the people you’ll need back fast. 10:21 to 11:20 After COVID, Offbeat shrank to its three co-founders, paid every severance, and planned to bring one staff member back in June 2022. Bookings returned faster than expected. In January she got a call asking if she could start tomorrow, and she quit her job that day. A community of people willing to support you is a big part of rebuilding.
  • Build online training and a yearly week of in-person training while you’re slow. 11:35 to 12:05 Offbeat’s experiences team spends a lot of time hiring and training guides. It built online training for program leaders and delivery staff early, when it didn’t need many staff. It also runs a week-long training every summer for seasonal staff. The core team and many program leaders are doing first responder training.
  • Run your processes in Notion and a cheap CRM before you buy anything shiny. 12:05 to 12:20 It’s easy to see a shiny product and want it all. Offbeat built its processes in Notion and kept its CRM cheap.
  • Move from everybody doing everything to separate sales, experiences and accounting teams. 12:20 to 12:33 Separating roles is the biggest change in how Offbeat manages its growth, along with training.
  • Buy a full booking platform when direct bookings get cumbersome and things start falling through the cracks. 12:38 to 13:50 One co-founder adopted a platform three years ago that manages bookings and vendor relationships, does accounting and ties into the CRM. It looked unnecessary when the business was mostly B2B. Now that direct bookings are growing, his team already knows it. The decision is knowing when to pull the trigger.
  • Use AI to grammar check and translate emails for staff working in their second language. 13:50 to 14:15 The AI doesn’t write the emails. It checks grammar and helps the team turn thoughts in Spanish into English. Staff who used to spend 30 to 40 minutes overthinking one email now finish much faster.
  • Segment your contacts in HubSpot so you can email one audience at a time. 14:15 to 14:25 Offbeat can’t send one HubSpot email to every contact, so it segments: all existing partners, all program leaders, or everyone who showed interest in the Dominican Republic in the past six months.
  • Take B2B payments by wire, group payments through WeTravel, and individual payments through Square. 14:32 to 15:05 Most of Offbeat’s payments are direct wires because the business is B2B. Groups sign up and pay through WeTravel, which makes sign-up easy and handles payment follow-up. Offbeat still uses the free account, which carries fees. Square covers some individual clients.
  • In affinity travel, you sell one group leader, and that person brings the whole group. 15:13 to 16:04 Student travel sells to one person, or a couple, at a school or another organization. That leader brings a whole group of students or adults along. It’s a great corner of the industry because you only have to sell the one person.
  • Win group buyers through networking and word of mouth, because they have to trust you with all their groups. 16:04 to 16:40 Follow-ups matter, but the sale comes from getting to know the person. Most of Offbeat’s business has come from word of mouth and networking, with little digital marketing. A buyer who trusts you won’t stop at one customer. They’ll send one group, two groups, or every group they have for your country.
  • Expect 6 to 8 months for the fastest B2B sale and 12 to 18 months for most. 16:40 to 17:05 A booking two or three months out is rare, usually a teacher in a bind. Most B2B partnerships take 12 to 18 months from the first conversation to the first traveler.
  • Keep going back to the same trade show for a few years before you judge it. 17:05 to 17:25 The first meeting might be at an event where you hit it off, or it might take years of showing up. Offbeat has gone to SYTA, the Student & Youth Travel Association conference, for three years. The first year brought little. Now people follow up and take the company seriously.
  • Have risk management, payment systems and a fast sales team ready before partners vet you. 17:25 to 17:50 Partners traveling with students want proof of risk management, payment systems, and a sales team that answers inquiries quickly. Under 24 hours is the floor. The real expectation is an hour or two, or even 30 minutes, with at least an itinerary or an idea.
  • Win over the partner’s leadership first, then make sure your sales team moves fast once leads arrive. 17:50 to 18:20 The first sale happens between leaders. Their leadership talks to yours, decides to trust you, and approves you as a vendor. Then their sales team starts sending leads to yours. If your team is slow, or doesn’t build rapport with the salesperson on the other side, the relationship work at the top goes to waste.
  • Run webinars that show partners your destination so they can sell it. 18:20 to 18:43 A partner may sell five countries and never have been to yours. Offbeat runs webinars showing what the Dominican Republic actually looks like, down to the hotels. Educating partners so they can sell your destination is a big part of a DMC’s job.
  • In a short trade show meeting, ask about the buyer’s goals before you say what you sell. 19:45 to 20:55 Nobody buys on the spot. Open with what they’re looking for, how their conference is going, and what experiences they want for their students. “It’s not like you’re going and selling toilets, you’re selling a relationship.” In a relationship, they have to like you. Buyers sit through over a hundred appointments that blur together, and a DMC talking a mile a minute gets glazed eyes. Sit down calmly and have a conversation, clock on the wall or not.
  • Make the buyer the hero of your pitch, with you as the guide. 20:55 to 21:42 One-sided pitches that never let the buyer mention which schools are interested don’t land: we’re the best, we’ve been around for years, we know every great guide. Donald Miller’s Building a StoryBrand frames it as the buyer being the hero and you being the guide. Show up, ask questions, understand their customer, and let them talk.
  • Ask open questions about what the buyer’s groups want, because you can’t pitch every program you run. 21:42 to 22:28 Asking what experiences a client wants can bring up an interest that matches something specific you offer. For Offbeat, a question about conservation led to its turtle conservation program and its access to a wildlife refuge the client had wanted to visit. Without the question, the refuge would never have come up.
  • Post on LinkedIn to get introduced into communities, and expect clients to come from those people later. 22:37 to 23:23 LinkedIn won’t lead to a sale every time. It leads to introductions: a post gets noticed, someone links you into a community, and the people you meet there become clients. That’s how Offbeat found Tourpreneur and got clients through it.
  • Show up in person again and again, because referrals go to the operators people keep seeing. 23:35 to 24:18 Being present at events over and over keeps you in front of people when someone asks them for a recommendation, even if competitors have better prices or connections. Marketing agencies and Google downplay this because it’s messy and you can’t track the ROI. It works because it’s human.
  • Use short storytelling videos as sales tools and send them when buyers ask how you do things. 24:18 to 25:08 Offbeat doesn’t do much on social media, but it has put money into human, locally told videos. A video about its staff training is used to onboard new staff and goes to every buyer who asks how staff are trained. It sits on YouTube and gets views, and it also works as a sales tool. One of the videos won an award at SYTA.
  • Make a short documentary about a signature program and send it to buyers. 25:08 to 25:40 Offbeat’s award-winning film about a local community and its marine conservation program in Puerto Plata goes out whenever that program is being sold. The video sells itself. Knowing how to tell the story of what happens on a program is a big part of the sales cycle.
  • Hire a former guide with film training to shoot your videos from a local point of view. 25:46 to 26:18 Offbeat’s videos are made by a former program leader who went to film school in Argentina and has led its programs. He knows the programs from the inside and, as a local, shoots them through a local lens. That also keeps the marketing money in the country.
  • Treat sustainability as company ethics instead of the lead in your sales pitch, and put safety and quality first. 26:29 to 27:20 Buyers aren’t yet deciding on local ownership and sustainability, so Offbeat doesn’t put them front and center in sales. Doing it costs the company nothing. Not every hotel can be locally owned, since many beach hotels are foreign owned, and in some places the better or safer operator isn’t local. Decisions about safety and quality come first.
  • Hire local leaders to cut costs on flights, housing and meals. 27:20 to 27:41 Local program leaders mean you don’t pay for a stream of flights into the country. Staff flown in also need somewhere to stay and eat between programs, while locals just go home. A lot of these choices simply make business sense.
  • Write a minimum group size into a volume deal, with a higher price below it. 28:16 to 28:50 Offbeat’s largest partnership sends 700 to 800 travelers a year across the Dominican Republic and Costa Rica, and that partner wants low prices. The deal holds the price as long as every session has at least 20 travelers, and below 20 the price can go up. The partner has kept 20 students on every trip, across 18 trips a summer in the Dominican Republic and 12 in Costa Rica.
  • Quote schools that come to you directly above your wholesale margin and below your partner’s price. 28:50 to 29:15 Wholesale partners get a lower margin because they resell the trip. A school or university that comes to you directly is used to seeing higher prices, so raise the margin. Keep the price below what that school would see from your partner: cheaper, but not much cheaper, so you make a bit more.
  • Walk away from a partner whose margin pressure leaves you working for almost nothing. 29:15 to 29:45 Offbeat ran eight trips for one partner over twelve months and netted 8,000 to 10,000 dollars, a 5 to 8 percent margin after issues. That margin pressure is a big reason the partnership ended.
  • Price normal work at a 30 to 40 percent margin, and drop to 15 to 20 percent only for very high volume. 29:45 to 30:00 You have to cover your staff and your team, so never price below what’s sustainable. A partner sending 700 to 800 clients a year can justify 15 or 20 percent instead of the usual 30 or 40.
  • For back-to-back sessions in one place, rent villas for the season and turn them into a base house. 30:00 to 30:37 In Constanza, in the Dominican mountains, Offbeat rented three villas usually listed on Airbnb for the whole season, added bunk beds, and ran four sessions back to back. A cook and grocery runs add legwork, but it came out far cheaper than the variable cost of a hotel without lowering quality.
  • Give student groups a private base with a pool, games and space to talk. 30:37 to 31:03 A custom setup shows the group you went out of your way for them. Hotels can feel impersonal. A house with a pool, a pool table and a ping pong table gives students their own campus, with no one else around for discussions.
  • Build a per-program budget sheet and price on margin instead of markup. 31:20 to 31:35 Offbeat’s sheet runs day by day with every activity and the exchange rates, which have caused real trouble lately. The team is asked for a margin, not a markup, with a minimum it can’t go below. The sheet does the math so the team doesn’t have to.
  • Tell your sales team to start quotes high and come down, even for clients they love. 31:35 to 31:57 A team that loves a client and is building a relationship tends to start the quote too low, and everyone negotiates. Start in the middle or high, then work down.
  • Calculate margin on ground cost, with overhead built into the minimum. 31:57 to 32:10 Offbeat’s margin is figured on ground cost. The minimum margin covers overhead: marketing, sales and salaries.
  • Hold your margin with partners who squeeze, because discounted trips are where you lose money and get unhappy guests. 32:25 to 33:08 Some partners squeeze hard. Others never question the price and often sell better. Over the past two years, every time Offbeat bent on price it went poorly. That’s where it lost money and where satisfaction was low, because the trip was sold too cheaply for the experience. Train your team to be honest about what you can and can’t do. Once prices start coming down, they rarely go back up.
  • Talk to your B2B partners as you start selling direct, before they decide you’re competing with them. 33:54 to 34:11 As Offbeat shows up more in the direct market, some partners are asking whether it plans to compete with them. It doesn’t, and these are conversations to start having now.
  • Rebuild your website so each audience can see who you serve: partner brands, schools and individual travelers. 34:11 to 35:07 Offbeat’s first site was a do-it-yourself Squarespace build and the second was by a designer friend. The third, built with a professional, speaks to each segment. On the old site, visitors couldn’t tell who the trips were for. The new site’s colors differ from the brand colors on the itineraries, so brand consistency is the next job.
  • Work with a conservation partner until its science becomes the student activity. 36:26 to 37:05 Offbeat’s marine program runs with a marine conservation foundation that didn’t want to deal with kids. Mixing its scientific work with student groups took time. Now the foundation sees the value and has an education person on staff.
  • For community service work, do real community organizing: go to the meetings, the birthday parties and the house openings. 37:05 to 37:30 A staff member attends community meetings, and the team shows up at birthday parties and at the opening of houses it built. Being present in the community is hard work and part of the job.
  • Let the community decide who benefits from a service project. 37:30 to 38:10 Students on the housing project questioned cementing floors when families needed whole houses with roofs that didn’t leak, so the project moved to building entire houses, which cost more. Choosing who gets the first house isn’t the operator’s call. Offbeat consulted experts, set criteria, presented the project at a community meeting and let the community decide. Within a couple of hours it had a ranked list of 20, and the team has worked from that list since.
  • Give students a real task inside the partner’s work, like a fish census on waterproof clipboards. 38:10 to 38:30 Scientists do the coral building and the diving, and not every student can dive. Students visit the coral farms with clipboards of waterproof paper and count fish to help with the scientists’ census. Finding a real role for students takes legwork.
  • Keep an operations team visiting suppliers and communities, and replace any experience that doesn’t work. 38:30 to 38:51 Most partners can’t travel to the destination every year, and those constant visits are the biggest value a DMC adds. The team drives out to communities and vendors, stays in touch to improve, and finds a replacement when something doesn’t work. Sometimes it designs an experience itself and trains someone to run it.
  • For upscale direct clients, hire from hotel sales and train those hires on group programs. 39:07 to 40:17 When Offbeat took on more independent travelers through OTAs, it hired people in each country from hotel management and hospitality who knew how to handle those leads. The newest hire came from hotel sales. She went through summer staff training and then ran a student program. The details differ: students get a box of water tossed to them at pickup, while an upscale client expects a cooler of sparkling and still water.
  • Hire for team fit over sales skill. 40:29 to 41:30 Offbeat’s staff have mostly come up from program leading, and it now hires more people from outside. A very charismatic salesperson who didn’t understand the culture or work well with others didn’t last. When another person left, the office realized how far one person had been dragging the team’s energy down. People who stay longer get better at the work, and how the team works together matters more than any one individual.
  • Screen seasonal guides for storytelling that fills the time, beyond moving a group from point A to point B. 41:30 to 42:12 Seasonal staff go through several rounds of interviews and background checks. Look for people who want students to get something out of the trip. Every guide says they love storytelling, and watching them in action shows how differently they mean it.
  • Get guides off their phones on the bus and back to games and pointing things out. 42:12 to 42:45 Too often a guide gets on the bus and sits on their phone. Bus time is the chance to point things out, talk with the group and play games like cards or Never Have I Ever. That used to be the default, and smartphones have worn it away.
  • Run phone-free programs. 42:45 to 42:59 Students without phones go through a few days of withdrawal, and by the end they don’t want the phones back.
  • Use transfer time for group activities, because that’s where bonding comes from. 42:59 to 43:32 Guests having their own entertainment doesn’t let guides off the hook. On multi-day trips, bus rides and transfers are where group activities create bonding, special moments and a sense of belonging.
  • A team that delivers lets you sell with confidence. 43:47 to 44:30 When a founder moves from running experiences to selling, knowing the team will deliver what’s promised makes the selling easier and more confident.
  • Learn cash flow before you start, especially in a seasonal business. 44:30 to 44:50 Seasonality makes cash flow tricky and stressful. It’s the part to study harder before launching.
  • Track when in the year you close sales. 44:50 to 45:09 Knowing which quarters and times of year your deals close lets you plan. Dig into those numbers.
  • Connect AI to your inbox, calendar and booking system, then ask when you close deals. 45:09 to 45:51 Connect Claude to your meeting calendar, your Gmail and your booking software, then ask when you close deals, what your average deal length is, and where your pain points are. The data is already there, and AI is very good at showing you what you can’t see across your own business.
  • Ask AI to search your inbox for missed sales opportunities. 45:51 to 46:06 The first question after connecting Claude to Gmail and the calendar turned up emails from people who never got a follow-up.
  • If you run day tours, pitch student travel companies, because one booking can be 20 to 30 kids. 46:17 to 46:48 Student travel is a big and fast-growing part of the market, too big to call a niche. Day operators can contact student travel companies and bring their groups on tours.
  • Student travel holds up in hard times because parents keep paying for it. 46:59 to 47:40 These trips happen at 14, 18 or 21 and can’t be put off ten years. Parents make sacrifices to pay for them even when times are tough, so student travel is less discretionary than most of the industry. The change in a student is built into the trip, because the memories are so different from daily life.
  • Treat student travelers as your future guides and customers. 47:56 to 48:28 Students who counted fish on those clipboards have gone on to study marine biology and come back to volunteer or fundraise. Someone who travels at 14 travels for life. Some group leaders today were students on trips 20 years ago. Offbeat just got a job application from someone who traveled with it as a student for the past five years.